
Current Issue
Inequality
Spring 2025, Volume XXIV, Number 3
Cover Image: Javier Ninanya Campos
Table of Contents
Editor’s Letter →
by June Carolyn Erlick
On Inequality: DRCLAS Former Faculty Directors

The History of Inequality
For the last few decades, a strong consensus has held that Latin America is not only the most economically unequal region in the world, but also one where inequality has become structurally entrenched. Even in countries where income levels are relatively high by global standards, a small elite continues to control a disproportionate share of national wealth. This consensus reflects a broader shift in the development community and public arenas.

Waxing and Waning: Institutional Rhythms of Inequality
Zelia Maria Magdalena Nuttall was famous in her time, well-known as an archaeologist, an Americanist, an antiquarian, an ethnologist, a folklorist and “a lady scientist”; she was a woman “making it” in a man’s world from the 1880s to the 1930s. Deeply engaged in research about ancient civilizations in Mexico, she led a remarkable life as a pioneer in the evolution of anthropology as a field of study.

The Biology of Inequality
Asked to write about inequality in Latin America, an evolutionary biologist would naturally think first of human history. Systemic inequalities among groups of people has taken many forms over the centuries, since long before the colonial era. For at least as long as there have been cities, there have been inequalities in access to resources, in the form of housing, employment, education and even food and freedom itself. These historic and continuing injustices are widely-recognized. What I wish to write about is the much less visible, but more pervasive, impact of a source of inequalities—the stress of experiencing discrimination—on health that is, perhaps surprisingly, an ancillary consequence of an even older human history of exposure to stress challenges in both our physical and our social environments.

"Ojos Propios" Photo Contest on Inequality
OJOS PROPIOS is very flattered by the vision of ReVista of our work, a kind gesture that makes us to want to continue contributing to the life and well-being of so many people and communities, especially in Peru, whose richness and variety of cultures has allowed us to forge a melting pot of knowledge and learning, whose fruits can be seen here.

Photoessay by Carlos Troncoso Matto (Ojos Propios)
I mostly get around the city on my bicycle, and that allows me new perspectives and points of view of my city. Unusual and unnoticed locations that allow me to photograph with a greater visual space, more independent of the permitted urban mobility restrictions.

Photoessay by Christian Vinces (Ojos Propios)
From the skies of Lima, the city reveals its crudest contrasts.
My work seeks to document the urban inequality that has intensified with the unruly growth of the city.

Photo Workshops Essay by Various Authors (Ojos Propios)
OJOS PROPIOS PARTICIPATORY PHOTOGRAPHY WORKSHOPS THROUGHOUT PERU

Photoessay by Romulo Lujan (Ojos Propios)
Cultural diversity and informal economic activities in urban public spaces. This type of scene highlights how many people depend on informal commerce for their income, showing the importance of these elite spaces for the local economy and popular culture.
Exploring Inequality

Afro-Latin American Studies: “La academia puede ayudar mucho”
“Nos toca crear nuestras narrativas y la academia puede ayudar mucho.” That is how Alí Bantú Ashanti, Director del Colectivo de Justicia Racial (Colombia), defined our work. As scholars and members of the academy, he suggested, our main task is to create spaces and opportunities for Afrodescendant communities to share, disseminate and reflect on their own narratives.

Stuck: The Spatial and Social Inequalities of Latin America
I love to ride the bus in Latin America. The range of parcels, the crammed-in commuters, the drivers outside my window swerving through city streets, and the criers announcing routes in sing-song tones make the experience better than any amusement park ride. But at some point, what always strikes me about the bus are the people who stay on long after all others have departed.

Inherited Inequalities in the Land of Pedro Páramo
“I came to Comala because I had been told that my father, a man named Pedro Páramo, lived there.” Thus, Juan Rulfo began Pedro Páramo, one of the masterpieces in Spanish-language literature. In this Mexican novel, the past continues to influence the present up until the point where the two of them overlap. The line that differentiates them subtly vanishes.

When the Water Rises, Inequality Overflows: A Tale of a Foretold Tragedy
Tatiane Flores, a physical therapist in her early twenties, arrived at the place where her first-floor apartment used to stand. All she saw was a pile of mud and debris. The acrid smell of dirty water still lingered in the air. “ Now I come here and don’t even know if I have a home anymore.

Photoessay by Gladys Alvarado (Ojos Propios)
Lima is a harsh, hostile, implacable, misunderstood and constantly changing city. You can get into a car and move forward, walk through its streets looking straight ahead, as if you were going through a tunnel. I think it demands an additional interest to stop and observe what surrounds us.

Photoessay by Javier Ninanya (Ojos Propios)
In Peru, economic fractures are a historical constant, starkly evident in the Andean region. Since colonial times, mountain communities have been marginalized by a centralized model that prioritizes urban and coastal growth, leaving high Andean populations on the margins of development.

Photoessay by Luís Figueroa (Ojos Propios)
Cusco is a cosmopolitan, touristic, traditional city, linked to Catholic religiosity and ancestral Andean practices. It is home to a fervent syncretic cosmovision and a permanent spirituality, linked like any growing city to a galloping economy and an effervescent commerce.

Photoessay by Leonel Gutiérrez (Ojos Propios)
On the iconic Jirón de la Unión street, tour guides emphasize the area, the architecture, the cultural heritage, etc., but deep down, the forgotten echo of the conomic and social contrast
Perspectives

Inequality as the Engine of History: Learning from the Past
Over two and a half centuries ago, in his influential essay “A Discourse on the Origin and Basis of Inequality Among Men,” Jean-Jacques Rousseau presented a persuasive argument: primitive human societies prior to the advent of agriculture, approximately 10,000 years ago, were inherently egalitarian.

A Look at Cuba: Growing Inequalities
Standing outside a store with a long—very long—line of people waiting to buy eggs, I started to chat with a woman in her 50s who lived in the Havana neighborhood.

Urban Divide: The Structural Roots of Housing Inequality in Tijuana
The transformation hits you as soon as you cross the U.S.-Mexico border.

The Legitimacy of Inequality in Mexico
Mexico is not a poor country; it is an unequal country.

Photography and Social Contrast (Ojos Proprios)
“It was said that I was doing aesthetics of misery.
Bullshit! I photograph my world”
Sebastião Salgado

Protests: Photoessay by Connie Frances Calderon (Ojos Proprios)
I submitted these three images to the contest because I believe they capture the essence of contemporary Peru: a country deeply marked by its social, political and political contrasts.

Photoessay by Eliana Sangay (Ojos Proprios)
This 2022 photographic series shows the urban dichotomy in Lima, especially on the border with Santiago de Surco and Pamplona Alta.

“EL PERÚ DE CONTRASTES”: Photoessay by Erick Aquino (Ojos Proprios)
“It was said that I was doing aesthetics of misery.
Bullshit! I photograph my world”
Sebastião Salgado

Photoessay by Yayo López (Ojos Proprios)
“It was said that I was doing aesthetics of misery.
Bullshit! I photograph my world”
Sebastião Salgado
Book Reviews

A Review of The Amazon in Times of War
Marcos Colón’s book The Amazon in Times of War offers a compelling collection of essays exposing the physical, economic and institutional violence that devastates the Amazon. He argues that much of this destruction stems from deliberate state policies enacted under former Brazilian president Jair Bolsonaro (2019-2023). Colón not only documents the struggles of Indigenous and other traditional communities but also critiques the role of profit-driven industries such as logging, mining and cattle ranching in the ongoing exploitation of the Amazon and its peoples.

A Review of Historieta Doble: A Graphic History of Participatory Action Research
In 1997, I attended the worldwide Action Research Conference in Cartagena, Colombia. One of the sessions opened a space for action research from industrial settings. I presented a project on learning in a network of small businesses in a region of Norway. A Mexican professor raised his hand after the presentation and said: “Excuse me for being direct, but do we live in the same world?”

A Review of Liberation Theology and Praxis in Contemporary Latin America. As it Was in the Beginning?
The book Liberation Theology and Praxis in Contemporary Latin America assumes great relevance with the shifting landscape of the Catholic Church under Pope Francis, whose papacy has signaled a renewed engagement with many of the themes central to liberation theology. From his emphasis on economic justice and ecological responsibility in Laudato Si’ to his advocacy for oppressed communities, Francis has revived aspects of liberationist discourse that were marginalized under previous pontificates.

A Review of The Return of the Contemporary: The Latin American Novel in the End Times
Latin America, and the world more broadly, has been mired in crisis throughout the first quarter of the 21st century. From economic downturns to ecological disasters to legacies of racism and enslavement, the neoliberal trends of past decades have permeated our daily lives with instability amid longstanding narratives of constant progress. If, as we are told, our society is constantly progressing, why has precarity abounded? In The Return of the Contemporary: The Latin American Novel in the End Times, Nicolás Campisi explores the ways in which contemporary Latin American authors confront these realities, focusing on the genre of the novel.

A Review of Cash, Clothes, and Construction. Rethinking Value in Bolivia’s Pluri-economy
A cottage industry of academic research on Bolivia has flourished over the past twenty years. Unleashed by popular mobilizations and political transformation around the turn of the century, social scientists have dissected and debated Bolivia’s “plurinational” state-building project, which came to define President Evo Morales’s regime (2006-2019). Of course, Bolivia had long been the object of scholarly curiosity, thanks to its robust Indigenous movements, neoliberal experiments in multiculturalism, eruption of anti-global uprisings and the postcolonial turn in public discourse.